Previous Press Releases
2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001December November October September August July June May April March February January
News Articles for April 2011
April 29, 2011
North African Crisis Could Test the Asylum System to Destruction
April 4, 2011
Cap on Economic Migration Will Have a Limited Effect
Full Text of Press Release : April 2011
North African Crisis Could Test the Asylum System to Destruction
The recent instability caused by revolutionary change and military conflict in some Arab countries in North Africa has the potential to generate substantial flows of migrants into the EU. EU Ministers will meet on 11 May to consider what might be done.
Some migrants will be genuine refugees but many will be economic migrants. Anyone who sets foot in the UK and claims asylum has the right under the 1951 Refugee Convention to have his or her case heard and also has a right of appeal if refused. Applicants are supported by the taxpayer throughout the process which takes months, and often years. The UK's record in removing those whose cases eventually fail is extremely poor.
In theory, the UK can return economic migrants who claim asylum to the EU country in which they first arrived but that requires proof of their point of arrival which is often impossible to obtain.
The countries of North Africa are already struggling with large and rapidly growing populations; now 170 million, they are projected to reach 215 million in 2030. Youth unemployment rates range from 18% in Morocco to 31% in Tunisia, giving a total of three million young unemployed in Algeria, Egypt, Morocco and Tunisia (no figures are available for Libya). See Briefing Paper No 9.29.
In recent times the Italians have circumvented the Refugee Convention by having the Libyan and Tunisian navies turn back economic migrants before they could set foot on EU territory. That arrangement is unlikely to continue.
There is now a clear risk of a massive inflow of economic migrants to the EU, many of whom will claim asylum. If this should happen we can expect much greater pressure on the Channel ports from those who prefer to seek asylum in Britain. The asylum system, already creaking, could collapse under the weight of numbers as it did in 2000 - 2002 when a peak flow left the Home Office hiding half a million files in a warehouse.
Commenting, Sir Andrew Green, Chairman of Migrationwatch UK, said "We must not bury our heads in the sand. We should build on President Sarkozy's proposal for humanitarian zones in North Africa to accommodate those who are displaced for economic or other reasons. This would make it easier for them to return home when the situation improves, as was the case with Afghanistan.”
Back to top
Cap on Economic Migration Will Have a Limited Effect
The Government’s cap on economic migration which comes into effect on 6 April will have only a limited effect on net migration in the medium term but it could become a barrier against future increases in economic migration. That is the conclusion of a paper published today by Migrationwatch.
Generous transition arrangements and effectively unlimited Intra Company Transfers (ICT's) should meet most employer needs and are certainly not onerous. Future numbers will depend on the extent to which employers use the ICT route. The present tax advantages of doing so must be removed so as to level the playing field for British workers some of whom are losing their jobs to immigrants, especially in IT.
The continuing flow of economic migrants makes it all the more important that the government should break the present almost automatic link between economic migration and settlement. There must also be much more effective measures to ensure the return of workers when their visas expire. These steps are essential of the government is to meet its objective of reducing net immigration from the current 200,000 a year to tens of thousands a year by the end of this Parliament.
Commenting, Sir Andrew Green, Chairman of Migrationwatch said "There has been some welcome progress but, despite the best efforts of Home Office Ministers, it is now clear that a number of key measures have been obstructed by Liberal Democrat objections. This may be inevitable in a coalition government but the public should be clear about where responsibility lies. Meanwhile, if the number of economic migrants shows any significant increase, public opinion will want these issues to be re-visited".
Note to Editors:
The two main weaknesses are the failure to place any cap on Intra Company Transfers and the decision not to abolish the Post Study Work Route, despite 20% unemployment among recent British graduates.
Back to top